Hard

Arbitrage betting: why a sure bet is guaranteed profit only on paper

It works on paper: sure bets come up often but are small, and bookmakers quickly cut the limits of those who catch them.

  • 40%of matches had a sure bet at the best closing prices
  • +1.4%the average profit of such a sure bet
  • 9.2%of matches had a sure bet of 2% or more

What a sure bet is

If the best odds on all the outcomes, taken from different bookmakers, imply less than 100% in total, you can bet on every outcome so that you win whatever the result.

An example: a home win at 2.10 with one bookmaker, a draw at 3.60 with a second, an away win at 4.20 with a third. The probabilities are 47.6% + 27.8% + 23.8% = 99.2%. Split the stakes in the same proportion (47.6 + 27.8 + 23.8 = 99.2 units), and any outcome returns 100: a profit of about 0.8%.

What history shows

At the best closing prices, 40% of matches formally had a sure bet, but the average profit was 1.4% of the total stake, and sure bets of 2% or more turned up in 9.2% of matches. At early prices there are fewer: 18% of matches, 0.7% on average.

An important caveat: the best prices were collected from dozens of bookmakers after the fact. Some of them lasted seconds; some were mistakes the bookmaker would cancel. There are far fewer real sure bets that you could get on in time.

Why it is hard

  • You have to bet with several bookmakers at once, before the odds change.
  • The profit is a fraction of a per cent, so you need big stakes — and big stakes mean limits.
  • Bookmakers spot “arbers” by their betting patterns and cut their limits to token amounts.
  • A bookmaker is entitled to void a bet at obviously wrong odds, and then the sure bet turns into an ordinary bet with risk.

This is an analysis of history, not advice to bet. Betting means risking money; 18+. The numbers: 43,288 completed matches in 27 football leagues between 15 July 2017 and 12 October 2026; bets on the match result (home win, draw, away win) after 90 minutes. In hockey and basketball the winner includes overtime; a hockey draw is the one after regulation time.

Other strategies